Why does neil kill himself

I just watched this movie with my mom for the first time tonight and had a few thoughts I want to share if that's alright The classic, "permanent solution to a temporary problem," is, in this great film, illustrated so beautifully Yes his father was, like most of that era, overbearing to the enth degree It is clear to me that this is not an evil father without love for his son Which is indeed, the wake up call most parents must heed as their teens who are still roughly years from full on copacity to merge wills with those of their family, and understanding as parents that our kids are not here to be our underlings - NOT born to assert the will of their parents Therefore, I must conclude that as tragic as it is to say and suicide always is it IS ultimately Neil who made that fated choice.

My heart is with any situation like this in fiction or in life I'm not saying "anything goes" - simply more understanding for why and how someone in particular this case since its a movie theoretical writing could end feeling the way that Neil does Keating was the cause of the negative events that occur in the film.

Of course not. As far as I am concerned, he was just doing his best to help those kids, trying to do his job as well as he could, and putting every effort in encouraging his pupils to think by themselves, something that certainly no other teacher did. Is that bad? No, definitely not. Was he, maybe, too enthusiastic at his endeavour? Maybe, yes. But, this alleged excess a verdict I don't agree with should be rather seen as natural and logic to counterweight the excesses in those good golden days: teachers and parents were too strict, too tough and too authoritarian with those kids; and that was no good either.

Personally, I think that having different ways of thinking is great and it makes this world better. Each one of us sees the world from a different perspective and everyone has their own opinion. What makes us unique and valuable as individual persons are those different thoughts, those new ideas or feelings that grow from ourselves.

Keating was just trying to show that to his class, to help them find their own likes and dislikes, to trust themselves and to see that as richness instead of a kind of sin. Sometimes we are too afraid of thinking, like Todd, and we just do what people tell us. Sometimes we just need something, a little of inspiration, a little spark, to help us get rid of this overwhelming feeling of guilt and insecurity, and start making ourselves owners of our lives, like Neil did.

Sometimes we are Romeos, like Knox, but we need that Julieta for getting up. However, sometimes we are like Cameron, and we do what we're told to, without breaking any rule or disobeying. It is the easiest way: you obey, you don't have any problems. Is it always easy to obey though? That would be another question.

We all had, are having, or will have a moment in our lives that will make us take the control of it, impose and talk by ourselves. Life offers us many opportunities to realise that we are actually capable of writing the script of our own lives, it is not an unexpected muse the one which makes the pen write, as it was not Mr Keating the one who pulled the trigger: we're more awake than we think and that others think!

Like it or not, Neil is the one to blame for his own suicide. It was Neil who chose to go behind his dream, like Keating told him, following the wrong road, like Keating told him NOT to do. Because that is all what this is about: about taking decisions, taking risks and foreseeing and assuming consequences.

That is all what this is about: freedom. Freedom is not free of pain and it is rarely the easy way, it is simply freedom. Sign up to join this community. Throughout the movie, there were scenes that showed how Mr. Perry's strict treatment destroyed Perry's identity. The film is based upon Victor discovering who his father was.

Regardless of this numerous flashbacks he had and memories of his father, this just does not compare to what it would be like if his father had been there with him as he grew up.

However Troy chose to stick with his son to raise him right, even though it was a form of tough love. When things got hard in between Troy and his family he could have easily left but that was not the goal. The queen told her son that he needs to be nice to his new dad. The only reason why he is going to be nice is because he respect his father wishes. Young Hamlet eventually finds out that Claudius killed his dad and things do not do smoothly.

He feels like he cannot trust anyone anymore. He feels like no one is on his side anymore. Amir had to go through each day by pretending like someone he is not for his dad. Amir also use to lack attention from his dad. Perry is known for his relentlessness and putting unnecessary pressure on Neil, forcing him to study and get a well-paying job, ultimately playing a part in his death.

He does this by discouraging Neil to pursue his acting career and is against letting his own son do what he feels satisfied with doing.

This is shown when Mr. This scene is portrayed as the camera angle facing up towards Mr. Perry, making him seem bigger and more…. He also went through so much with no one being by his side and supporting him, though he stood by his father's side he was with him through life and death. He loved his father thus making him idolize him. When he discovered the murder of his father he planned to avenge him like at that time any son would have done for a parent.

While playing Puck in Henley Hall's production of Midsummer Night's Dream, Neil allowed himself to indulge in the more impish side of his personality while both acting and outside of it. He was seen to be more daring and careless.

Despite that, he remained terrified of standing up to authority, namely his father, as shown when Charlie's prank almost led to the Dead Poets Society to discovered. The relationship between Tom Perry and his kid is a very strained one. Perry believes that it was their so-called creative and inspiring teacher John Keating corrupting Neil with his carpe diem lessons. The movie does not explicitly outline their relationship. It appears that they both struggle to stand up to Mr. Perry, as his mother fails to say anything when Mr.

Perry threatens to send Neil to military school. Charlie and Neil seemed to have been best friends, with a certain sense of familiarity indicating they have seemingly been close friends for a very long time. After Neil's death, Charlie seemed to act more irrationally, which caused their expulsion from Welton when they punched Cameron in the face for selling out Keating to Mr. It is speculated that they have kissed.

Since they were roommates and Todd was new to Welton, Neil found it important to include Todd in their conversations despite the latter being extremely shy. Todd was extremely reluctant to build a friendship with any of the Dead Poets Society members, yet Neil encouraged him to do so by finding ways to make Todd comfortable with the situation.

Neil always tried to inspire Todd to speak up for himself and compared him to Walt Whitman in regard to his poetry.