[PDF] The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power by Richard Primus
The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power by Richard Primus
- The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power
- Richard Primus
- Page: 448
- Format: pdf, ePub, mobi, fb2
- ISBN: 9780674293595
- Publisher: Harvard University Press
Download The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power
Free google books download pdf The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power by Richard Primus 9780674293595
A groundbreaking challenge to a core principle of constitutional law, arguing that congressional action is not limited by the legislative branch’s textually enumerated powers. Every law student learns that the federal government is constrained to act only according to its enumerated powers, meaning that Congress can do what the Constitution expressly authorizes it to and nothing more. Yet Richard Primus contends that this longstanding orthodoxy—allegedly required by the text of the Constitution, the Framers’ vision, and the logic of federalism—is fundamentally flawed. Through careful analysis of constitutional text and history, and of the structure of American federalism, The Oldest Constitutional Question builds a powerful argument for broad congressional authority. In particular, Primus shows that the primary function of enumeration is to rule listed powers in, not to rule other powers out. The Framers were more worried that the federal government might be fragile and anemic than that it would be overwhelmingly strong. Enumerating congressional powers is thus best understood as a way of ensuring that the federal legislature has an incontestable warrant to exercise the powers specified there, not as an exhaustive description of all that Congress can do. In practice, the enumeration of powers does little to limit Congress. But most constitutional lawyers—including many Supreme Court justices—think this means something has gone wrong, such that the courts must aggressively strike down federal laws exceeding Congress’s enumerated powers. Primus’s meticulous examination explodes the prevailing view, revealing its underlying errors. The constitutional system does place limits on Congress, and crucially so, but the enumeration of powers is not, and never has been, a sensible means for creating and enforcing those limits.
Popular Sovereignty and the Power to Choose a Government
Jefferson Powell, The Oldest Question of Constitutional Law, 79 Va. L. Rev . constitutional federal issues. This suggests that these powers are at .
David Schleicher on X: "Buy his great book here https://t.co .
Buy his great book here. The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power. From amazon.com · 1:52 PM · May 27, 2025.
5Qs: Richard Primus's New Book Asks the Oldest Constitutional .
Here, he discusses the arguments that he lays out in his new book, The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power (Harvard .
[PDF] The Constitution United States of America - GovInfo
The most up-to-date version of the Constitution of the United States of America,. Analysis and Interpretation (Constitution Annotated) is available online at .
[PDF] The Original Meaning of Enumerated Powers - Iowa Law Review
Enumerationists are committed to the idea that the Constitution limits federal power through a strategy of categorical ex ante enumeration, .
Books about Federal government - BiblioVault
front cover of The Oldest Constitutional Question. The Oldest Constitutional Question. Enumeration and Federal Power. Richard Primus. Harvard University Press .
Article I, Sec. 8: Federalism and the Overall Scope of Federal Power
Federalism at the Founding can therefore best be described as “Enumerated Powers Federalism.” The national government was conceived as one of limited and .
Richard Primus on the Threat to the US Constitutional Order
Pre-order Professor Primus' book The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power. If you haven't already, I also recommend you .
The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power
A groundbreaking challenge to a core principle of constitutional law, arguing that congressional action is not limited by the legislative branch's textually .
[PDF] IT IS A CONSTITUTION WE ARE EXPOUNDING
The American Constitution Society for Law and Policy is a national nonprofit edu- cational organization with a rapidly growing membership of lawyers, .
Baby Ninth Amendments - Project MUSE
The Baby Ninths not only first needed the federal Ninth Amendment to survive spirited debate and ratification, but a series of antecedents had to be invented.
The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power
A groundbreaking challenge to a core principle of constitutional law, arguing that congressional action is not limited by the legislative branch's textually .
The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power
The Oldest Constitutional Question: Enumeration and Federal Power ; ISBN13: 9780674293595 ; Publisher: Harvard University Press ; Published: Jun 3 2025 ; Pages: 448
ARTICLE II VESTS THE EXECUTIVE POWER, NOT THE ROYAL .
Article II of the United States Constitution vests “the executive power” in the President. For more than two hundred years, advocates of presidential power .